By Larry Cohen (C) 2026
There are some stories that if I don’t tell them, no one will. What I mean is that, while they are etched in my memory, no one else alive that I am aware of will even know nor care about these not so great events that would never make it into anyone’s historical record. Yet, these events really occurred. The following is but one example of such an event
There is a location in Herkimer County called Chepachet. I can’t be sure of the original pronunciation but I pronounce it as it is spelled with the accent on the second syllable. While there may have been a town there at one time, as of this writing there is nothing there but an old railroad station. And, that’s where this story begins, at this “location.”
I have always thought and continue to think that the area in Southern Herkimer County as well as that of northern Otsego County are the most picturesque areas of New York State. The “rolling hills of New York” begin and end in this part of the State.
One day I was driving in Columbia Township along NYS Route 51 at the very southern tip of Herkimer County when. I passed an old weathered wooden sign with an arrow that pointed toward Chepachet. As a lifelong resident of Oneida County, the adjoining County to Herkimer County, I would have thought that I would have heard of every nearby town, village and hamlet in Herkimer County by the early 1970’s. But, Chepachet? I never heard of the place (probably because it’s not much of a place). I had to find out about Chepachet.
As mentioned, the only building of significance that I saw was what appeared to be an old train station left over from the heyday when electric trains traversed the entire State of New York. I noticed that there still was a functioning railroad crossing that I later found out was a spur line out of Bridgwater, NY., whereon a freight train came by once a week with only two or three freight cars with lumber or feed for a local lumber yard and feedmill in Richfield Springs. One could walk faster than the train traveled since the condition of the track was questionable.
However, upon closer inspection I realized that this former railroad station was now a bar. Not being a stranger to bars by that point in my life, I hopped up the steps and into the train station turned bar, a place where the walls were now lined with old farm implements, a collection of cow bells, and a large working fireplace, giving the entire establishment a nice bucolic flavor.
Since it was not prime drinking time, I was able to strike up a conversation with the bar owner who told me how he and a friend decided to transform the old train station into a bar as a sideline to their regular job, one who had something to do with the Township of German Flatts, also in Herkimer County, and the other who worked for Sears-Roebuck in the Village of Herkimer.
Now that the stage has been set, I can get to the heart of the story. I asked about the rail line that was still there and, as mentioned earlier, learned that it was operational but the train only came through one day a week. I also learned that they had befriended the engineer of the train since he became a familiar face passing by every Wednesday morning.
And, that’s when the idea struck the two new bartender-entrepreneurs. They decided to “rob” the train One day, a Wednesday morning, of course, they dressed up as cowboys, borrowed two horses from nearby farms, and with faces covered by their bandanas, they decided to hold up the train.
With 9-shot .22 pistols held high in the air, riding horses, dressed up as Western cowboys, they each rode around the train hoping to give their friend, the engineer, a good laugh.
Well, by chance, that day, that Wednesday morning, their friend had called-in sick and a stranger was now the engineer, not their friend.
The substitute engineer stopped the train and came down from the engine with his hands in the air, terrified. He thought it was a real holdup, despite the fact that there was no strongbox full of gold on the train but only lumber and corn.
When the “hold up men” saw this they, too, were just as terrified. They apologized profusely and had to bring the engineer into the bar for a few cups of coffee (and probably a shot or two of whisky).
This is a true story.
Discover more from The Daily Post
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Thanks for putting Chepachet back in the limelight. Like you I used to travel the backroads of upstate to see the many near-ghost towns up there. Back in the 70s most had a bar (and only that)-the only really important businesses in upstate and stopping by was a priceless experience. I see that Chepachet had a “General Store” once, and a B&B still resides there which probably would be a delight.
Another unsung small town train robbery occurred in “Frontiertown” NY some time in the 70s or 80s. This fake village hosted fake cowboys (like the ones singing country today), fake Native Americans and a rodeo, but most remembered was the fake “train robbery” on the 1/4 scale tourist train. Until it wasn’t fake one day. Some enterprising young men decided to hold up the train upstream from the hired actors doing the same, and make a good stash of beer money, All went well while tourists willingly handed over their wallets–until one of the “participants” slugged one of the tourists. Meanwhile the actors upstream wondered what happened to their train. And like your story I bet this one is nowhere to be found today.
thanks
Fritz